If it seems too good to be true…

An Iranian-Jewish blogger for the Los Angeles Jewish Journal savages the Daily Telegraph for running that infamous Ahmadinejad-has-Jewish-descent story:

After reading the Telegraph’s original story published yesterday and consulting with a number of local Iranian Jewish scholars with regards to the story’s claims of Ahmadinejad’s supposed Jewish identity, as an Iranian Jewish journalist I cannot verify a single shred of evidence that would suggest this story is accurate in anyway. The article lacks any real or credible sources cited that can unequivocally prove that Ahmadinejad had any Jewish roots and it seems as if the story was just leaked to the Telegraph by “reformist” leaders in Iran as a part of a larger smear campaign against the newly “re-elected” hardliner president of Iran.
Another serious question I have with the accuracy of McElroy and Vahdat’s story is their claim that Ahmadinejad’s alleged Jewish name “is even on the list of reserved names for Iranian Jews compiled by Iran’s Ministry of the Interior”. Again I am perplexed at why these seasoned journalists would place any kind of credibility on an official Iranian government document when most experts familiar with the current Iranian regime know very well that anytime lists of names are “complied by the Iranian government” they are used by different forces in the regime for nothing more than to attack another official, party or faction in the country. The most classic and detrimental way Iranian government officials have attacked one another is to claim that the “such and such official was born a Jew, or was once a Jew who converted to Islam, or his family was Jewish a generation ago and then converted”. The “Jewish identity label” is your classic textbook example of anti-Semitism at its prime that is thrown around as a type of public insult or verbal assault officials in Iran and in most Islamic nations used against one another in smear campaigns. The Iranian Jewish experts I interviewed this morning in L.A. informed me that for one Iranian government official to call or accuse another government official of being Jewish is the equivalent to individuals or groups in the U.S. to accuse an elected official in America of being a child molester or pedophiliac! [sic] This is the sad and unfortunately reality that being a Jew in Iran has a very derogatory meaning.
The negative connotation of claiming that someone Muslim in Iran is Jewish or has Jewish roots brings me to my final analysis of the true origins of this entire Ahmadinejad-Jewish story. Iran experts here in L.A. I recently interviewed said that even before Ahmadinejad, various “reformist” leaders during the “open era” of the past Iranian President Mohammad Khatami during the 1990s and early 2000s were using “Jewishness” as a verbal assault against other rival officials they hated or against other Iranian officials who presumably had Jewish blood. …

Via Elder of Ziyon.

2 thoughts on “If it seems too good to be true…

  1. segacs says:

    Irony: One of Ahmadinejad’s top advisers was one of the perpetrators of the (obviously false) “Hitler-was-Jewish” myth. MEMRI reported in January 2007 that Mohammed-Ali Raman claimed that Hitler’s paternal grandmother was a “Jewish prostitute” and that Hitler’s desire to rid Europe of all Jews stemmed from his loathing of his own past, and oh, by the way, the Holocaust was part of a plot to found the state of Israel because Hitler identified with his Jewish past… or something… made even more bizarre by the rampant Holocaust denial from the Ahmadinejad camp.
    (On the one hand, the Holocaust didn’t happen, but on the other hand, it did happen and was responsible for the state of Israel…???)
    Yeah, trying to puzzle that out just induces a headache.
    Original article here, in case you’re interested: http://www.ynet.co.il/english/Ext/Comp/ArticleLayout/CdaArticlePrintPreview/1,2506,L-3347309,00.html

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s