Obnoxiousness isn’t always a crime

The skeet who yelled a sexist meme at NTV reporter Heather Gillis during a live shoot has been acquitted of criminal charges:

A provincial court judge in St. John’s has ruled it could be illegal to shout a sexist slur at female reporters, but not in the case of what happened to NTV reporter Heather Gillis last year outside the city dump.

It was never a question of whether Justin Penton hurled the words at Gillis while she was interviewing St. John’s Mayor Danny Breen at the Robin Hood Bay waste management facility in April 2017. The issue for the judge was whether or not it constituted a crime in that context.

Gillis reported she was “humiliated, embarrassed and disgusted” by the comments. Breen said it made him uncomfortable.

But Judge Colin Flynn ruled an emotional disturbance does not meet the criteria for a charge of disturbing the peace.

“Something more than emotional upset and a momentary interruption in a conversation is needed to constitute the criminal offence,” Flynn wrote in his decision.

[…]

Last April, Gillis had just finished interviewing Breen, who was a city councillor at the time, and was following up with a few off-camera questions. Penton drove by in his truck and yelled “F–k her in the p—y” on his way into the dump.

A lower court judge is bound by Supreme Court of Canada decisions, and in this case it appears that Judge Flynn is following the 1992 Lohnes decision.  He even suggested that Parliament could, and probably should, add “emotional disturbance” to the Criminal Code provisions regarding causing a disturbance.

Needless to say, the University of Twitter College of Law respectfully disagrees:

1

Twitter is angry about a court decision.  Dog bites man.  But even many of Newfoundland’s blue-checkmarks are calling out the decision:

Screenshot from 2018-02-20 18-55-23Screenshot from 2018-02-20 18-55-39Screenshot from 2018-02-20 18-56-41

Newfoundland’s media world is a small one, in which most local journalists know each other well, so it’s not surprising to see the province’s media personalities coming to the defense of a colleague.

But would so many reporters, commentators and entertainers be piling on this if it didn’t happen to someone from their own world?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s